top of page

Why Protein Comes First

Writer: Mark Offerdahl
Mark Offerdahl
Sep 7
3 min read

You can train hard all week and still leave most of it on the floor if the plate after class is an afterthought. At CrossFit Uncommon we treat protein like the first decision of the meal, not a side note.


Muscle building is not a vague vibe. It is a switch. When a meal delivers enough high quality protein, especially from animal foods, that switch flips and repair starts. When it does not, almost nothing happens, no matter how good the workout felt.


This is education for people who train. It is not medical advice.


Your muscles stop listening when the meal is light


Every hard session creates a demand for amino acids. The signal that turns repair on is tied heavily to leucine, and animal protein is dense with it. Six ounces of beef or a solid plate of eggs clears the bar in one sitting. Matching that from plants usually means a volume of food almost nobody actually eats.


Build the plate around the animal first. Beef, lamb, eggs, fish. Then add what you need for fuel. That order is the whole game.


The threshold goes up as you get older

A twenty something can often flip the switch on roughly 20 to 25 grams of protein in a meal. Past forty, the research points closer to 35 or 40 grams to get the same response.


Most people are eating a third of that at breakfast. Toast and coffee is not a recovery meal. Eggs and meat are.


Aim for about 40 grams of protein per meal if you train and you are not in your twenties anymore. That is the practical rule we use on the floor when someone asks what to eat.


Hit the daily target, then spread it


For people training hard, the upper end of what the research supports sits around 1.6 grams of protein per kilogram of bodyweight per day. For a 180 pound athlete that is roughly 130 grams a day.


Stacking all of it into dinner does not work as well as spreading it. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner each need a real serving. Paul Saladino and other animal based practitioners often push even higher targets for active people. Start with consistency at 40 grams per meal and build from there.


Source matters


Not all protein counts the same. Animal foods give you the full amino acid profile in the form your body absorbs best. That is why we say start with the animal, skip the seed oils, and eat the whole animal when you can. Liver, marrow, and slow cooked cuts cover gaps that chicken breast alone never will.


Cook in butter, tallow, or ghee. Read labels. If the first ingredient is canola or soybean oil, put it back.


What this looks like after class


- Protein first: beef, eggs, lamb, fish, or organ rich meals

- About 40 grams per meal

- Daily total near 1.6 g per kg if you train hard

- Carbs from fruit or honey when you need fuel

- Skip ultra processed protein snacks that are mostly seed oil and marketing


Bottom line


Train hard. Eat enough protein from animals. Spread it across the day. That is how the work you did in the gym turns into muscle instead of just soreness.


Want help building this into your week? Book a free intro at CrossFit Uncommon in Austin and we will meet you where you are.


Not medical advice. Educational content only.


Want to go deeper? Here is Paul Saladino on how much protein to eat.





bottom of page